Mutiny – Familiar Formula, Satisfying Action
There is something reassuring about a Jason Statham action film. You ...
Rosie Richardson takes the stage at a New York open mic hoping to get a few laughs. Instead, she learns that her mother has died, and everyone in the room hears the news with her. That is the opening sequence for ‘Funny/Not Funny’.
The detail I like most about this opening is that Rosie still asks for another go at her set. What else is she supposed to say to a room full of strangers? She came there to do comedy. A few seconds later, she’s still trying to get through the evening she thought she was having.
In this Michelle Leung short film, things get stranger when a package arrives from Rosie’s mother. Inside is a robot vacuum. It’s the sort of practical gift a mother might buy because she thinks her daughter could use one, which is precisely why it gets under Rosie’s skin. Even after she’s gone, her mother is still finding ways to be part of her day. Rosie decides to get rid of it. Returning a package is a job she knows how to do, and right now that’s enough to keep her busy.
Jocelyne O’Toole, who plays Rosie and contributed in developing the screenplay, lets her character be cross, impatient and a little unreasonable. I appreciated that about the performance. There’s a scene where Rosie turns up at a shipping counter dressed as a clown, and the costume is probably the first thing anyone there would notice. By then, we know enough about her day to see why she has so little patience for any of this. Leung has cited The King of Comedy as an influence, and you can see it in how willing she is to let the awkwardness of a public encounter play out. The laugh can come a second before you realize how badly you feel for Rosie.

I was less taken with the thread about Rosie teaching a comedy class to get another shot onstage. I understand why she’d go through with it. A gig is still a gig, and she wanted that stage before any of this happened. But the film gets to the class so quickly that I barely had time to register what another set would mean to her. The story picks up again when it gets back to the package, where Rosie’s frustration feels more specific to her and to the woman she’s just lost. O’Toole has spoken about how her feelings towards her own mother’s death changed over the years she spent writing the film. That comes through in the affection underneath Rosie’s irritation.
If I had to pick one thing that makes the short work, it’s the choice of gift. A heartfelt letter would have told us what her mother wanted to say. A vacuum leaves more room to wonder what their relationship was like. Maybe this was simply how her mother showed she cared, by noticing something Rosie needed and sending it over. It’s easy to see why Rosie would want it out of her sight that day. It’s just as easy to imagine her missing it later.
The film doesn’t complicate things with its look and feel. It keeps all those visual elements simple, and the art direction is well in line with what you would see in a comedy club. The simplicity in things makes
But beyond all of that, Funny/Not Funny is a pleasant short film that you can watch several times. And even though it does seem like a story worthy of a feature-length exploration, you can’t help but hope there was more to it. Maybe that is something Michelle Leung and the rest of those involved in the making can consider.

Leave A Reply